Enjoy Liza’s latest and join in the water cooler debate.
Four more American Idol contestants exited stage left, leaving the 12 finalists in place. Idol Critic’s Liza Persky breaks down this week’s competition and asks the important questions:
- For a man who embraces his baldness, why does Phil Stacey always wear a hat?
- Who is Gina Glocksen and what was up with those song lyrics?
- Will Lakisha’s Auntie and Momma get their own show?
- And what the hell was Antonella Barba wearing this week?
Tune in now because Idol week isn’t over until the Idol Critic sings.

My favorite!
I can’t believe that Haley & Sanjaya made it. Sanjaya…Whya?
good one again…totally agree about Melinda and the back up singer stuff. I say she’ll win in though. Loved the sanjyay bit