The American Idol contestants tackle the classics and Liza Persky swings.
The venerable Tony Bennett stops by and gives the Idol crew some pointers. Most of them don’t listen, but no matter.
The Idol Critic’s questions are what matter:
- Why do Blake’s teeth disappear when he sings?
- Who doesn’t believe in Mindy Doo?
- Is LaKisha displaying a bit of a ‘tude?
- What in God’s name was going on between Ryan and Sanjaya’s father?
The competition is heating up, but the Idol Critic is as cool as the other side of the pillow.

That’s funny stuff. You guys really get it, in the right way. Can’t believe Gina’s out…..Not expected….
Give this woman a TV show, for God’s sake!!!
I agree with Joy and Wonder. I LOVE Idol Critic, but how am I going to get my Liza Persky fix when Idol is over?! She needs a spin-off.
you could not have said it better… i agree with everything you said! you are the best idol critic out there!
Dear Sherman,
Have no fear…have you not heard of Liza’s other fabulous website…www.39secondsingle.com???? You can get another Liza fix every Friday all year long!!
You’re welcome.
P.S. Liza, the Larry “Bud” Melman reference was classic…you are seriously too funny.